Claire Weatherly owns a shop that sells Amish wares in Heavenly, Pennsylvania. She lives with her Aunt Diane, who runs the local B&B. Working closely with the Amish gives Claire an insight that many ‘English,’ non-Amish, do not have. When her assistant, Annie, reveals an Amish man was found dead in his barn, she says it was God’s will. Considering there’s a shovel next to the body, it seems it was someone else’s will as well.